Ranking the top 20 NFL head coaches of all time - Sportsnaut (2024)

Imagine any coach going to four straight Super Bowls in the modern era. That’s what Levy’s Buffalo Bills teams did in the 1990s. Unfortunately, they could never win the Lombardi Trophy, but Levy still deserves a place in coaching history.

Related: NFL QB Rankings 2024: From Patrick Mahomes to Jarrett Stidham

TheMinnesota Vikingshave never won a Super Bowl, but Grant’s Purple People Eaters became one of the best football teams in the 1970s, creating thousands of fans worldwide.

Related:NFL teams that have never won a Super Bowl

A member of the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Stram’s Kansas City Chiefs were dominant in the 1960s and 70s, both in the AFL and NFL. In all, Stram won two AFL Championships and one Super Bowl. He also was thefirst head coach to be mic’d upduring a game, paving the way for a new era of football content.

Related: Ranking the greatest undrafted players in NFL history

Peyton Manning and Tony Dungy led the Indianapolis Colts to seven consecutive double-digit win seasons, peaking in 2006 by finally getting that ever-so-elusive Lombardi Trophy. With how excellent the Colts were in the early 2000s, it’s hard to leave Dungy off any mention of the best football coaches of all time.

Related: Best 5th round NFL Draft picks ever: From Tyreek Hill to Lester Hayes

With a few more successful seasons, we’re bumping Tomlin ahead of Cowher, but for now, we like the latter’s playoff success more than the former. Cowher’s success with the Steelers can’t be forgotten, and unlike most of Tomlin’s career, he didn’t have a franchise quarterback.

Related: Best 6th Round NFL Draft picks of all time, including Tom Brady and Terrell Davis

Tomlin has been at the helm in Pittsburgh for 17 seasons, and yet he’s never had a losing record. Most importantly, in 2009, at the age of 36, Tomlin became the youngest NFL head coach to win a Super Bowl (Later topped by Sean McVay). He’s now in the top 15 on the NFL’s all-time wins list, with over 170 victories, and consistently leads one of the best defenses in football.

Related:NFL Top 100 players in 2024: Patrick Mahomes, Micah Parsons and the best NFL players

Parcells is one of the most respected head coaches of all-time, and for good reason. ‘The Big Tuna’ was far from a ‘nice guy’, but players certainly responded to his tough love. The proof is all in the two Super Bowl trophies sitting at the New York Giants’ headquarters.

Related:2024 NFL defense rankings

While Jimmy Johnson’s reign as the Dallas head coach only lasted five seasons, it sure was glorious. We can still hear “How bout them Cowboys” coming through our TV sets 30 years later. Curiously, Jerry Jones moved on from Johnson after winning his second consecutive Super Bowl in 1993, the ‘Boys haven’t won the big game since.

Related: 20 funny Dallas Cowboys memes

Is John Madden one of the greatest coaches of all time? The impact Madden had on the game of football cannot be overstated. He may have only coached for ten seasons and retired back in 1978, but his .759 winning percentage still ranks second-best in NFL history. He’s the perfect example of quality over quantity.

Related:2024 NFL Power Rankings: Reviewing all 32 teams

There have been just four coaches to win three or more Super Bowls. Joe Gibbs did his best work during the 1980s and 1990s, leading the ‘Hogs’ to four league championship appearances. His 70% win percentage in the playoffs also has to be considered when ranking the best football coaches of all time.

Related: NFL playoff predictions

As the only head coach to win at least 100 games with two different franchises, Andy Reid deserves a special place in history. While his 14-year tenure with the Philadelphia Eagles was impressive in its own right, what he’s done with the Kansas City Chiefs will help get ‘Big Red’ into the Hall of Fame. Of course,Patrick Mahomeshasn’t hurt, and now the duo has won three Super Bowls together, but we have a feeling they’re not done. Reid’s passed Landry for fourth on the all-time wins list, but he’s just getting warmed up.

Related: Best 7th-round NFL Draft picks of all-time: From Julian Edelman to Brock Purdy

Not only was Curly Lambeau the founder of the Green Bay Packers, he led them to six league championships. It’s only fitting they named the stadium after him, and now everyone knows Lambeau Field. Heck, it’s been seventy years since he was roaming the sidelines, and the name Lambeau has yet to lose any pull.

Related:NFL offense rankings: See where your team stands

Tom Landry made the Dallas Cowboys ‘America’s Team’ thanks to leading his groups to five Super Bowl appearances in the 1970s. His 250 wins still rank fourth all-time in NFL history, and his 20 playoff wins come in at third place. A coach who was ahead of his time, Landry was credited with inventing the 4-3 base defenses that teams still use heavily today.

Related: Best NFL Draft classes ever: 10 best classes in NFL Draft history

Not only was Paul Brown the founder of the Cleveland Browns, but he was also part of getting the Cincinnati Bengals off the ground. Going to ten consecutive championship games and winning seven, Brown is absolutely one of the greatest coaches in football history.

Related: Highest paid NFL players 2024: Highest paid players by position, average NFL salary

If you’re familiar with The Steel Curtain, then you should also be aware of Chuck Noll, whose Pittsburgh Steelers won four Super Bowls in a six-year span. He paved the way for being a Steelers legend and deserves a place among the best coaches in NFL history.

Related: Greatest 3rd round NFL Draft picks ever: From John Lynch to Travis Kelce

When sports figures speak of riding off into the sunset, they dream of doing what Bill Walsh did, retiring after winning his third Super Bowl with the 49ers. But he earned an early retirement after completing six consecutive double-digit win seasons. Walsh developing the now-famous West Coast offense only puts the cherry on top regarding his coaching excellence.

Related:Super Bowl winners: Most Super Bowl wins, Lombardi Trophy history

Halas’ place in history will be hard to forget, as his 318 wins rank as the second-most in NFL history, as does his six league championships. Halas did it all, from playing the game to coaching and even founding and owning the Chicago Bears, which is still operated by his family to this day. There’s a reason the NFC Championship Trophy bears his name. George Halas was a legend.

Related:15 longest field goals in NFL history

There is only one coach who has ever led an NFL team to a perfect record. His name is Don Shula, and he also holds the record for the most wins in NFL history. The ’72 Dolphins may very well be the greatest football team of all time, and who would we be to discredit the coach who led Miami to six Super Bowls?

Related:NFL MVP odds 2024

Who is the greatest NFL head coach of all time? In the NFL, the ultimate goal is to chase a Lombardi Trophy. Which, until Bill Belichick came along, meant every other football coach was trying to live up to Vince Lombardi’s legendary accomplishments with the Green Bay Packers. We’re just going to leave you with this. “We’re trying to get a seal here!”

Related: Best 2nd Round NFL Draft picks of all time, including Davante Adams and Brett Favre

Is Bill Belichick the greatest coach ever? In football, when it comes to the greatest head coach of all time, we have to give the title to Belichick. Winning six Super Bowls is more than anyone else, and unlike those who won league championships, Belichick did it in the modern day, with football as advanced as ever.

He has a total of nine Super Bowl appearances, and his competitive itch isn’t going away any time soon. It will be difficult for anyone to dethrone ‘The Hoodie’ from his spot as the greatest coach in NFL history, but that’s what they said about Shula and Lombardi too.

Related:Who is the highest-paid NFL coach? (Today and All-Time)